Protecting Your Access To Health Care Freedom In Massachusetts

An interview with Diane Miller, JD, by Spirit of Change publisher Carol Bedrosian



Published:

The right to freely live and work as you choose is enshrined as the bedrock of our free society in the Constitution of the United States. The State may not restrict your liberty — nor do you need permission — in the pursuit of vocation or happiness as long as you are not causing harm to others or defying existing laws of order. When a risk of harm is identified, it is the State’s responsibility to issue laws and restrictions that protect the public welfare. This is the basis for many types of professional licensing mandated by individual states for services that have been determined to carry a risk of potential harm to the public. Absent this risk, states have no constitutional basis for demanding licensure of personal livelihoods.

When the Massachusetts Senate unanimously passed legislation in July 2018 (that subsequently did not move forward in the House later that month) requiring the licensure of a host of holistic health professionals, including such benign modalities as Reiki, Yoga and Tai Chi, concerned consumers and practitioners sprang into action to protect freedom of access and the right to practice complementary and alternative health care in the state. While state legislators cited human trafficking concerns as the mandate for the expensive and burdensome licensure requirements, professionals across numerous industries, as well as the State Department’s own published report on combatting human trafficking, pointed to the need to bolster Massachusetts law enforcement resources overseeing business establishments, rather than unfairly singling out one profession for licensing and government-endorsed education. Human trafficking happens in all businesses; it is not isolated to one group of health care practitioners.

The firestorm generated by this licensing controversy highlighted the already ongoing efforts of Health Freedom Action Massachusetts (HFAMA), a non-profit aimed at passing safe harbor practitioner exemption legislation in the state for complementary and alternative practitioners. All fifty states require licensure for the legally and broadly defined practice of medicine. However, these broad definitions can technically deny an unlicensed person the right to deliver any type of healing service to the public without fear of retribution for practicing medicine without a license. And in some states that can even include you, Grandma, and your famous chicken soup!

Enter Diane Miller, JD, an attorney and Legal and Public Policy Director for National Health Freedom Coalition (NHFC) and its sister lobbying organization, National Health Freedom Action (NHFA). For well over two decades, Diane has worked to protect the right of all people in the United States to access all health care information, services, treatments and products that they deem beneficial for their own health and survival. To date, she has worked with people in thirty states, including HFAMA, to address their state laws surrounding the practice of medicine and delivery of health services.

As the co-moderator of the US Health Freedom Congress and as an educator, lobbyist, and advocate for collaboration, Diane’s work involves state, national, and international health freedom advocacy including: promoting safe harbor exemption state laws for homeopaths, naturopaths, herbalists, and state laws for medical professionals to practice holistic and integrative care; protecting access to dietary supplements and truthful health claims about them; advocating for laws that mandate labeling of GMOs and other toxic substances; protecting consumers rights to decline vaccines or other dangerous medical treatments, and the rights to choose non-toxic health options; protecting access to raw milk, organic food, and natural resources; protecting Mother Earth and her natural resources; and finally supporting leaders who are working to impact the decisions of international forums in order to protect health freedoms around the world. She is the author of The Principles of Health Freedom.

“I believe that laws and customs must be carefully reviewed, revised, and even repealed if necessary, and new ones created, to reflect the continual development, evolution, and spiritual maturation of a people,” notes Diane, as she discusses medical licensing laws in this interview.

 

Help NOW and join us in meeting with legislators at the Statehouse!

Email Clark Reddick at alphabioticsboston@gmail.com for the Spring 2019 daily meet-up times.

 

Carol Bedrosian: How did you get involved in writing health freedom legislation?

Diane Miller: After receiving my medical technologist degree, I decided to go to law school. I was asked to be on a case of a farmer who was charged with practicing medicine without a license in Minnesota. He was helping people by using colostrum from his dairy herd, and he was shut down for practicing medicine without a license. I was asked to be on the case to read the medical records of that case, and eventually I became co-counsel as it went forward. The farmer had cured Congressman Berkley Bedell of Lyme disease and other issues, and it was a very visible case because there were so many people who had been cured of many ailments, including cancer.

I was shocked to see how they could shut a farmer down for practicing medicine without a license. So I looked to see what that law was and I eventually found out that in almost every state, the definition of the practice of medicine includes almost all healing. Anything you do to prevent, cure, treat, ameliorate any disease, wound, fracture, deformity or immediate defect for any person in many states is considered the practice of medicine — and it has criminal charges with it if you’re not a licensed medical doctor.

The law also includes an exemption list of people who would be exempt from those criminal charges, such as other licensed professionals — nurses, chiropractors, etc. In that exemption list the only unlicensed public domain healers are included by state; some states have an exemption for prayer, spiritual healing. Iowa has an exemption for people who heal with water from the springs of their farm. Massachusetts has an exception for clairvoyants. So, literally, this farmer could have been charged just for helping people with anything from his farm, and I was really shocked about that. I said that’s just wrong, that’s a wrong law. So we fought for his freedom and we got two hung juries working as pro bono attorneys, and they were going to go forward with a third trial when the state decided to withdraw all the charges.

Carol Bedrosian: Why did they withdraw the charges?

Diane Miller: My understanding is that it may have been because they had already spent over a million dollars trying to prosecute the farmer and we kept defending him and there were a lot of people who were angry that they were prosecuting this farmer who wasn’t hurting anyone. Since the prosecutors always have discretion as to what cases to take forward in the public interest and since they had lost twice, I believe that they just decided to withdraw the charges.

When the jury members saw the law, they were very confused. One of the jury members was a schoolteacher who worried if somebody got hurt on the playground and she put a Band-Aid on their knee she might be charged criminally. Some people said that it would mean Grandmas giving out chicken soup would be criminally charged. The law was very, very broad for unlicensed practitioners, which most of the culture used to be before doctors became licensed in surgery and drugs. So I looked at that law, and when I found out it was almost in every state, I said let’s change that law in Minnesota. And it was a very big challenge. I’m writing a book now about how we helped to change that law in Minnesota.

With the national work that we now do, we have supported groups in states that have also gotten together to change that law. There are now ten states that have what we call “safe harbor practitioner exemption” laws. This new type of legislation is not like going and asking the government for permission to do a healing act like a licensing law does in order to do a dangerous act. It’s a different model that says as long as you’re not doing anything dangerous, you’re free to practice in the public domain, provided you avoid doing any of the prohibited acts listed in the statute, and you also provide certain required disclosures that define who you are, what your training is, and notice that you are not licensed as a conventional health care professional. The new laws create a safe harbor box that an unlicensed healer in the public domain can practice in. And if you go outside of that box you could be charged under the regular criminal act of practicing medicine without a license.

Carol Bedrosian: We’re working on this now in Massachusetts. Is this the tenth state that you have worked with in passing some kind of a safe harbor act?

Diane Miller: We have worked with about thirty states. There are a number of states in process right now. Ten of them have passed. Two of those ten were historical; there were old laws on the books already that were partial exemptions. Minnesota was the first that did a full exemption.

Carol Bedrosian: What does a full exemption include?

Diane Miller: It would include the broad domain of complementary and alternative health and healing practitioners that are not state licensed health care professional as long as they were avoiding the prohibited acts and giving out all of their disclosures.

Carol Bedrosian: What are prohibited acts?

Diane Miller: The prohibited acts list is developed by the people passing the bill and the legislators in that state. Each state is very different as to what is on that prohibited acts list. Minnesota has a list of 28 prohibited acts. An unlicensed complementary and alternative health care practitioner can’t puncture the skin, they can’t give out prescription drugs. They can’t do a chiropractic adjustment. In Minnesota we include ethical considerations such as a practitioner can’t have sexual contact with a client. So, there are a number of prohibited acts in Minnesota. Most states have a prohibited acts list. The states that are working on the legislation develop their own prohibited acts list to make sure that unlicensed people are not doing things that their state would consider to pose danger to a client.

Carol Bedrosian: What has the effect of this safe harbor law been in Minnesota?

Diane Miller: I love it. It’s almost 20 years now that we’ve had the law.

Carol Bedrosian: Have people been brought forward on charges of practicing medicine without a license since then?

Diane Miller: Not that I am aware of. All of the unlicensed people work under Minnesota 146A, or as we call it, the Complementary and Alternative Health Care Practice Act. They don’t have to get permission to practice before they practice. It’s not like a licensing or registration statute. They are practicing in the public domain and they’re practicing within the safe harbor parameters. If they go outside the safe harbor box, that is when they could be charged or disciplined by the Minnesota Department of Health.

Carol Bedrosian: But basically it’s people who are not causing harm.

Diane Miller: That’s right. If you’re not posing imminent risk of harm to the public, there is no reason for you to need to get permission to practice your vocation.

Carol Bedrosian: So, for instance, a Reiki practitioner poses no imminent risk of harm.

Diane Miller: Right.

Carol Bedrosian: Or a meditation teacher or a yoga teacher or many of the alternative therapies that are unlicensed.

Diane Miller: There’s a lot of difference between education and treating a person. If you’re a yoga teacher and you’re teaching a class, that’s education and this bill does not apply to or restrict education and educators.

Carol Bedrosian: Did you find states that did not have the practicing medicine without a license law?

Diane Miller: No, I have not. Every state that I have researched has a law that you cannot practice medicine without a license. And the definition of the “practice of medicine” is different in every state. All the doctors are licensed and they have a definition of what practice of medicine means. Some of them are more narrow, some are broader.

Carol Bedrosian: Such as massage being licensed in Massachusetts.  

Diane Miller: Massage is licensed in some states. In Minnesota we have always opposed massage licensing because we don’t believe massage is dangerous and it should always be in the public domain under a safe harbor bill. We just have local licensing for some of the cities for massage.

The United States is really about people being able to practice their professions and their vocations and make a living in a free society. The states are responsible for keeping the public safe. So the states say, “Well if you want to do something dangerous then we need to put some restrictions on it.” But if you’re doing something like painting houses or mowing lawns or whatever your vocation is, it is your livelihood. There are many people who have the vocation of healing that are not doing dangerous things. They’re doing a whole host of complementary and alternative healthcare things. Homeopathy, traditional naturopathy, herbalism, qigong. They’re giving out advice about food and nutrition.

So what we’re trying to educate the public on is that there are a lot of vocations in the public domain that have to do with healing that should remain in the public domain and not be funneled into the dominant medical structure. The government does not have the constitutional right to demand licensing of any vocation that’s not posing an imminent risk of harm to the public. The only time it can act in terms of setting up licensing statutes is when they think something is dangerous, because the state is the steward of the people. They don’t give out permission and rights. The people have the rights to do what they want to in their life and the only time the state can step in is when they’re causing danger.

That’s different than other countries where the monarchs gave a privilege for people to act. That’s not how the United States was set up. We said people are free to act and then the government can act to serve the people if needed, when and if there’s a problem. So, we are teaching the legislators that they should not demand licensing for things that are not dangerous. Many legislators don’t know that.

It has become commonplace regarding the healing arts and professions to provide state licensure where the states set up administrative Boards and demand practitioners get particular education from particular schools, and put restrictions on all others that do not have that training, even when the profession is not causing any public harm. Some vocations move forward to seek licensure just so they can get government endorsement and insurance coverage. Constitutionally we do not think that is a valid reason why states can mandate licensing and make other people criminals. Instead of depending on their own academic and good reputation, some professions want the government to do the rubber stamp, but that’s not what government is for.

Carol Bedrosian: In Massachusetts we are trying to pass health freedom legislation in response to bills that have been introduced requiring a large group of bodywork practitioners to receive licensing in order to practice in the state. Bodywork was defined very broadly to include many holistic practitioners who do not consider themselves bodyworkers.

Diane Miller: When our national organization saw that your state was going to try and mandate licensure by the government and forced education on all of these practitioners, we were very upset and worked to support the efforts in Massachusetts to defeat that bill and to try and help educate the legislators about licensure issues and also to introduce the concept of a safe harbor exemption act for practitioners that were not causing imminent risk of harm to the public.

The ten states that have safe harbors are wonderful examples of protecting access for consumers to these gentle yet powerful therapies where practitioners spend a lot of time with their clients. In Minnesota I can just pick up the phone and call a homeopath, an herbalist, a traditional naturopath, a shiatsu practitioner. I have a plethora of wonderful people at my fingertips and that’s the kind of health care that some people use to keep well. The environment that the safe harbor practitioner exemption laws create in a state are very nurturing, yet they let a practitioner’s credentials speak for themselves through the disclosures. For people who have maybe only had two weeks of herbalist training, when somebody wants to go to them, they have to disclose that. Someone else might be able to disclose I’ve been trained for 27 years in India.

Carol Bedrosian: That’s for the consumer to do their own education, and like anything else that you purchase, you search out reviews ahead of time and do your research as to which product or practitioner you will choose.

Diane Miller: I’m looking forward to supporting the Massachusetts group going forward. Our National Health Freedom Action organization is extremely supportive of Massachusetts having a safe harbor protection act. I hope the legislators think it’s a really great common sense solution, too.

The advocacy work of Diane Miller and staff at National Health Freedom Action in educating citizens of any state about passing health freedom legislation is funded by donation only. Please support this important work at www.nationalhealthfreedom.org.

To find out how you can participate and support efforts in passing this legislation in Massachusetts visit Health Freedom Action Massachusetts at www.hfama.org.

We need help meeting with legislators at the Statehouse NOW!

Email Clark Reddick at alphabioticsboston@gmail.com for the Spring 2019 meet-up times.

 

Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module Edit ModuleShow Tags

Daily Astrology

March 20, 2019

Happy Spring! This is a hyperactive day, astrologically one of the year’s busiest. The Virgo Moon is on a dizzying path all morning while feisty Mars forms an empowering trine to Pluto. Fortunately, Mercury’s timely late morning sextile to Saturn helps…
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Alternative Health Directory

Browse all listings »

Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Calendar

March 2019

Sunday afternoon: 3–4:30pm at Hillside Herbals Spring Tonics II: the spring tonic herbs—it's about circulation, assimilation and elimination—tincturing. Rachel has...

Cost: Drop in Fee $10 includes all materials and handouts.

Where:
Hillside Herbals
Jefferson, MA


Sponsor: Hillside Herbals
Telephone: 508-847-8615
Contact Name: Rachel Ross
Website »

More information

Show More...
Show Less...
No Events

Show More...
Show Less...

March 20–23 9am-3pm each day Experience transformation guided by Mother Mary. Through Divine vibration, you will be aligned for quicker healing and evolving with mind body spirit and...

Cost: $500

Where:
, MA


Sponsor: The LoveLight Center
Telephone: (207) 216-9584
Contact Name: Cheryl Banfield

More information

The American Center for Bioregulatory Medicine and Dentistry (The BioMed Center) is the most comprehensive center in North America for bioregulatory medicine and dentistry. Come see what...

Cost: Free and open to the public

Where:
111 Chestnut Street
Providence, RI
View map »


Website »

More information

Discover how you can release tight muscles and improve range of motion in locked joints in a weekly ESSENTRICS stretch classes led by Raindrop Fisher, certified Essentrics instructor. Raindrop is a...

Cost: $10 drop-in / $100 for 12 classes

Where:
Village at Waterman Lake
Function Room - Chalet Bldg
715 Putnam Pike
Greenville, RI  02828
View map »


Sponsor: Healthier Fit Lifestyle
Telephone: 401-678-0950
Contact Name: Raindrop Fisher
Website »

More information

Show More...
Show Less...

This 8 week series in Tai Chi will provide you with everything you need to get started in a personal Tai Chi practice. Just for Beginners—there is no expectation, and no pressure in...

Cost: $137 for 8 weeks

Where:
Spiral Path Connections
218 Boston Street
Unit 104
Topsfield, MA  01983
View map »


Sponsor: The Spiral Path
Telephone: 978-314-4264
Contact Name: Johanna Hattendorf
Website »

More information

Show More...
Show Less...

“All we need is love” the Beatles claimed in 1960’s. In fact, we have been looking for love from the beginning of time. We are conditioned that it is love which brings us...

Cost: $35

Where:
Circles of Wisdom
386 Merrimack Street, Suite 1-A
Suite 1-A
Methuen, MA  01844
View map »


Sponsor: Circles of Wisdom
Telephone: 978-474-8010
Contact Name: Cathy Kneeland
Website »

More information

“Master your breath, let the self be in bliss, contemplate on the sublime within you.” —Krishnamacharya Join us for an evening of deep exploration and transformation using the...

Cost: $30 (some hardship rates available)

Where:
Spontaneous Celebrations
45 Danforth Street
Jamaica Plain, MA  02130
View map »


Telephone: 617-233-6410
Contact Name: Allen Howell, M.Ed.LMHC
Website »

More information

Show More...
Show Less...

Only $225 if you register for both days! Save $25! Please click here to register for both workshops. This is a 2 day course being held Saturday and Sunday, March 23...

Cost: $125

Where:
Circles of Wisdom
386 Merrimack Street, Suite 1-A
Suite 1-A
Methuen, MA  01844
View map »


Sponsor: Circles of Wisdom
Telephone: 978-474-8010
Contact Name: Cathy Kneeland
Website »

More information

Former Buddhist monk and world renowned healer, Seth Monk, will be giving a Siddha Healing to our community. Seth will be accompanied by Shannon Fitzgerald, an AromaReiki Master for a beautiful...

Cost: $35

Where:
Sohum Yoga and Meditation Studio
30 Lyman Street, Suite 108B
Westborough Shopping Center
Westborough, MA  01581
View map »


Sponsor: www.SOHUM.org
Telephone: 508-329-3338
Contact Name: Ritu Kapur
Website »

More information

In her art and spirit workshops, Melissa combines her gift as an intuitive with her extensive background in painting to help you to work through creative blocks and learn or refine technique. Come...

Cost: $150

Where:
Circles of Wisdom
386 Merrimack Street
Suite 1-A
Methuen, MA  01844
View map »


Sponsor: Circles of Wisdom
Telephone: 978-474-8010
Contact Name: Cathy Kneeland
Website »

More information

Journey back into the experience of peace, harmony and inner power through this unique meditation practice. Explore the power of your thoughts and how they can bring you inner harmony and help you...

Cost: Free

Where:
Inner Space Meditation Center & Gallery
1110 Massachussetts Ave
Cambridge, MA
View map »


Telephone: 617-547-1110
Website »

More information

Psychics, mediums, angel readers, spirit art. Reiki, chair massage, IET, Gaiadon Heart, crystal healings, etc. Sign yourself up for a few appointments and bring your friends! Appointments...

Where:
Women Of Wisdom
118 Washington Street
North Easton, MA  02356
View map »


Telephone: (508) 230-3680
Website »

More information

6 Saturdays 10am–11:30am February 23–March 30, 2019 Taijiquan (Tai Chi ) is a healing martial art, using breath and movement together to strengthen the body and quiet...

Cost: $120

Where:
Metta Wellness
679 Pleasant Street
Paxton, MA  01612
View map »


Sponsor: Metta Wellness
Telephone: 774-245-5487
Contact Name: Rick Rocha
Website »

More information

Show More...
Show Less...
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module Edit ModuleShow Tags